Sunday, November 1, 2020

More on Bakhtin's Carnival

I was reading Eugene Slepov's recent essay on Confederacy (see below for citation). In general, I think it is a good essay and makes good points about nativity as being like ethnicity and about the importance to a character's identity of the time and place from which that character comes (or as the Beowulf poet would say, þæm dæge ond þysses lifes). He makes an important connection between place as a constituent of identity in Percy's Moviegoer as compared to Confederacy. I would have liked for him to have cited the work of Sara Dunne on the act of moviegoing with regard to place in Confederacy, The Moviegoer, and Catcher in the Rye, but that's me.

Slepov begins the essay contrasting his theory of carnival to Bakhtin's theory of carnival. He states that John Lowe, in his essay "Carnival Voices," relied on Bakhtin's theory, whereas Slepov instead sees Ignatius in the role of scapegoat. Here, I sat up and took notice, because I have several times commented on the contrast between Bakhtin's theory of carnival and the earlier tradition that culminated in Frazer's theory of carnival, which features a scapegoat figure.

I even went back and reread Lowe's essay, because I don't think of his essay as being anti-scapegoat. In fact, I think of it as an essay very much in the camp of pro-scapegoat, and one of the few that is pro-scapegoat, so I was surprised by the Slepov's discussion. My conclusion is that Lowe's position is more complex than Slepov suggested.

(Side note: When I had originally read Lowe, I was looking primarily for any comparisons he made between Confederacy and other texts. Rereading it, I see that Lowe articulates a theory of humor. I may study that theory of humor in a later blog entry. In my own writings, I may have borrowed some more ideas from Lowe than I have given him credit for.)

As for Bakhtin himself, Bakhtin seems studiously to ignore the role of the scapegoat in the history of carnival. In his book on Rabelais, he even cites Frazer, but doesn't mention this central feature of Frazer's theory. Why? I think Bakhtin's goal is to create a vision of a utopian "second life" in which all social status and dominance hierarchies are abolished in a revel of immersing ourselves into the regenerative and transgressive potential of the lower bodily stratum and a mythic folk laughter that is not singling any one person out for ridicule.

Bakhtin's supposed folk laughter is primarily ridiculing the "first life" of social orderliness controlled by political authorities. He overlooks the fact that humor is often directed by those of higher status against those of lower status even in a carnival setting. IMHO, Bakhtin's goal is part of a broader agenda of minimizing the fundamental nature of humans as social animals who naturally form interpersonal status hierarchies. I have criticized Bakhtin elsewhere for not having a fully general theory of humor.

It is, of course, impossible to transport oneself back to a previous era and conduct psychological tests to establish that the folk laughter of the medieval times was different than the laughter of, say, the Enlightenment, so many claims that Bakhtin states as obviously true cannot be disproven. His focus on Rabelais is brilliant, because carnival in Rabelais is not typical of carnival traditions generally, which often have a mock social hierarchy and feature a ritual purging of chaos as revelers get back to their lives. Bakhtin's utopian vision has been embraced by literary critics since the 1960s, perhaps in part because of its denial of social status hierarchies in the revolution of the people's laughter.

As for Lowe, he brings in the parts of Bakhtin that do relate to Confederacy, such as Ignatius's grotesque qualities, which wallow in the lower bodily stratum. But the center of Lowe's essay is comparing Confederacy to an ethnic melee, which is a comic drama that often features a scapegoat. So Lowe's approach to Confederacy is much closer to Slepov's than Slepov would lead one to believe. Confederacy features a scapegoat, Ignatius, and he is a figure that the reader is invited to laugh at, the agent of chaos to be celebrated but then expelled as the social order is reestablished, which is a situation very much unlike Bakhtin.

(More awkwardly, Lowe also lists nativity as a form of symbolic ethnicity (page 182), leaving Slepov very little room left to introduce novel points to the discussion. Lowe then goes further than Slepov into the study of ethnicity, making Lowe's essay the stronger of the two.)

Slepov, Eugene. "Singularities of Time and Place: A Study of Nativity as Ethnicity in A Confederacy of Dunces." Southern Quarterly. v. 56, no. 2, (Winter 2019), 8-21.

Thursday, October 1, 2020

Cutting Room Floor Series, part 4, The Clown Motif

In my new paper, "A Theory of Humor (Abridged) and the Comic Mechanisms of John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces," just published as a book chapter in Theology and Geometry: Essays on John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces, I had to toss out some thoughts because of space constraints. This series of posts, called "The Cutting Room Floor," publishes some of those items dropped from the final paper.

Cutting Room Floor Item Number 4: The Clown Motif

In my book chapter, I have a brief discussion of physical comedy. I had a paragraph that ties physical comedy to clowns. Here it is:

Related to physical comedians are clowns, and Confederacy has a clown motif. Gus’s factory produces what look like clown pants; Irene’s bad makeup is similar to a clown’s; and Ignatius’s hospital gown is “clownlike.” At one point, Ignatius prays to St. Mathurin, the patron saint of clowns. FN: Toole, Confederacy, 83, 100, 291, 197.

Tuesday, September 1, 2020

Buried in the Endnotes, part 4: Patteson and Sauret's Three Versions of Ignatius

Because readers often do not study the endnotes to a paper, I want to highlight information buried in the endnotes. This is the fourth post in this series.

In my new paper, "A Theory of Humor (Abridged) and the Comic Mechanisms of John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces," just published as a book chapter in Theology and Geometry: Essays on John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces, I discuss in the text the comic contrast between how Ignatius portrays himself and how others see him. In the endnote, I explain that Patteson and Sauret describe three Ignatius's. Here is the endnote:

Patteson and Sauret perceptively argue that Ignatius’s situation is more complex that a simple contrast. To them, there are three versions of Ignatius in the book. First, he sees himself as a crusader against corruption; second, the other characters see him as a selfish buffoon; however, the third Ignatius has retreated into a world of illusion after a painfully awkward childhood in order to avoid being humiliated by rejection and alienation. Ignatius’s outrageously childish behavior insulates the reader from feeling too much pity for him, but this third Ignatius gives the reader some sympathy for him, even as the reader laughs at his humiliations.
The second Ignatius is a comic rebuttal of the false facade of the first, but the third explains how Ignatius became the person he is. This third Ignatius creates in the reader sympathy for him and tinges him with tragedy.

Saturday, August 1, 2020

Cutting Room Floor Series, part 3, The Seven Word Summary

In my new paper, "A Theory of Humor (Abridged) and the Comic Mechanisms of John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces," just published as a book chapter in Theology and Geometry: Essays on John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces, I had to toss out some thoughts because of space constraints. This series of posts, called "The Cutting Room Floor," publishes some of those items dropped from the final paper.

Cutting Room Floor Item Number 3: The Seven Word Summary

I am a fan of the Ig Nobel Prize, organized by Marc Abrahams of the Annals of Improbable Research. The Ig Nobel Prize is a comedy award for scientific research that first makes you laugh and then makes you think. An example was the 2018 Prize in Medicine which was given to researchers who used roller coasters to hasten the passage of kidney stones.

The invited lectures at the Ig Nobel ceremony are called the 24/7 lectures, and they have two parts, a clear explanation of the research in 24 seconds, and a summary of the research in seven words.

As part of my early drafts of my "Theory of Humor" paper, I had an abstract which could be read out loud in 24 seconds, and a summary in seven words. The essays in the book do not have abstracts, so I dropped those elements. Here they are:

Full Abstract in twenty-four seconds: A Confederacy of Dunces (Confederacy) by John Kennedy Toole uses the comic devices of farce and concurrent incongruities to generate its humor. The overarching incongruity of the book is between how Ignatius Reilly sees himself and how the reader sees him. Ignatius’s primary personality trait is his selfish immaturity, and he is both trickster and tricked. Toole may have drawn on concepts of the trickster and fool available at the time he wrote the novel from thinkers in psychology, sociology, history, and literary studies.

Brief summary in seven words: To understand Toole’s Ignatius, read Enid Welsford.

Wednesday, July 1, 2020

Buried in the Endnotes, part 3: The Act of Damning

Because readers often do not study the endnotes to a paper, I want to highlight information buried in the endnotes. This is the third post in this series.

In my new paper, "A Theory of Humor (Abridged) and the Comic Mechanisms of John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces," just published as a book chapter in Theology and Geometry: Essays on John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces, I point out that there are three times in the plot where one character damns another character, and those curses seem to carry weight. Here is the endnote:

In this regard, the act of damning seems to be significant, as only the blocking characters in the book are damned. Gonzalez damns Mrs. Levy, George damns Lana Lee, and Ignatius’s mother eventually tells him to go to hell. Toole, Confederacy, 112, 190, 365.
I argue that Toole uses the device of the blocking character, who prevents other characters in the story from developing and rising in status within the social group. There are three blocking characters who through comic comeuppance are displaced from their social blocking posts, and in all three instances, another character tells them to go to hell or says, "Damn you!" I interpret this to mean that Toole took the act of uttering the curse "Damn you" to be important.

Monday, June 1, 2020

Theology and Geometry: the Second Half of the Book

On February 1st, I posted on this blog a discussion of Kenneth McIntyre's essay called "Amusingness Forced to Figure Itself Out." I said that it was the essay from the first half of the book Theology and Geometry: Essays on John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces that got me to stretch my thinking most. I then mentioned in my (somewhat self-serving) Amazon review that the essay that got me to stretch my thinking most in the second half was Anthony Cirilla's "Dunces and Dialogue: Ignatius J. Reilly’s Menippean Misreadings and Onanistic Annotations of Boethian Philosophy." I will comment on that second essay here.

Cirilla's essay is rather complicated. One major point made is that Ignatius's masturbation, which is a form of sex which does not communicate with another person, is analogous to his stunted understanding of Boethius's Consolation of Philosophy. He cannot have a relationship with either a woman or a text. Both feature a failure of responsibility. And that failure is a failure to have true communication, an inability to have a two-way exchange. One nugget of the essay is this: Boethius himself compared a fool chasing lawsuits to a yapping dog. In other words, Boethius, in the very book Ignatius idolizes, anticipates Ignatius's bestial nature. Cirilla also sees Ignatius's intellectual work as a form of masturbation, connecting semen to his seminal work.

One error I discovered in the essay was the misattribution of an idea. Cirilla attributes an idea about Abelman and Cain to my writings, whereas the idea is actually found in Tison Pugh's first version of the essay "It's Polly Fulla Dirty Stories," p. 86. But even here, Cirilla builds on the idea, pointing out that onanism comes from the Genesis story of Onan, whom God kills not for masturbating, but for neglecting the duty to the wife of his deceased brother. He also points out that Ignatius is titillated by seeing the hidden Lana Lee masturbating to Boethius, symbolic of his own approach to the philosopher. Perhaps the best quote from the essay is: "Unlike Lady Philosophy who uses language to marry Boethius’s mind to comforting truths, Ignatius uses his language to uncouple himself from others" (151).

Friday, May 1, 2020

Best of John Kennedy Toole Scholarship (unnumbered): Pugh, Queer Carnivalesque

I started the "Best of" series after I had read almost all of the criticism then available on A Confederacy of Dunces (ca. 2012). I ranked the criticism by my own measure of its relative quality. However, especially with the publication of Theology and Geometry, there are now many studies that would be inserted into my "Best of" list and alter the ordering. So the "Best of" list should now go unnumbered. Perhaps it should have been unnumbered from the get-go.

In February's blog post, I discussed the first half of the new collection of essays on Toole. I noted that the essay which got me to stretch my thinking the most was McIntyre's. In the second half, one essay I found especially interesting was Tison Pugh's study on Toole's queer carnivalesque (or is it his queering of the carnivalesque?). This is Pugh's third essay on the queer aspects of Confederacy (although the second is a revision of the first). All three are solid contributions to the field, and I recommend them. I would like to discuss Dr. Pugh's latest essay here.

Citation: Pugh, Tison. "John Kennedy Toole’s Queer Carnivalesque in A Confederacy of Dunces." In Theology and Geometry: Essays on John Kennedy Toole's A Confederacy of Dunces. Edited by Leslie Marsh (Lanham: Lexington Books, 2020), pp 105-122.

Annotation: I particularly like this essay in the collection, because Pugh opens by defending the theory of carnival put forward by Bakhtin. In my own essay, I discuss Bakhtin and argue that the theory of carnival put forward in James Frazer's Golden Bough is a better framework for interpreting Confederacy than is Bakhtin's theory. Pugh begins by assuming that Bakhtin's theory of carnival is the correct theory with which to study carnival. He then shows that Bakhtin's theory does not fit Confederacy. He argues that Toole "queered" carnival by portraying it in a way contrary to Bakhtin. So Toole transgressed the theory that carnival is transgressive. In this double negative way, Pugh perhaps unintentionally agrees with me that Confederacy does not fit Bakhtin's theory of carnival.

On a practical level one can see the effect of this implicit rejection: Pugh agrees that the end of the book holds up the theme of rebirth and renewal. He just skips over the fact that that theme supports Fraser's theory of carnival. Thanks Tison!